What’s Your WHY?

Sue Patterson
Listen to the Podcast

Why IS Unschooling A Good Idea?


Everyone's "Why?" is a little different.
Sure, when we hear some people's reasons to unschool, we quickly think,
"Yeah! I agree with that one!"

But back up a little more.

  • What's YOUR reason to do this?
  • Why did you choose to take such an unconventional approach?
  • Why, when most people go left, you chose to go to the right?

It certainly would have been easier to go with the flow and do what everyone else is doing... but something pushed you. And I want you to think about what it is/was.

There are as many reasons for unschooling as there are families who make this choice. Home education, in general, offers freedom along with responsibility - freedom to make our own decisions regarding how we wish our children to live and learn. Whatever initially leads parents to make this choice, it nearly always evolves into something far more than an alternative educational choice - it becomes a lifestyle choice of personal responsibility and freedom and incredible joy. Many families find unschooling is a natural step in this direction.

Like so many others, we unschool because we caught a vision of what learning and living without schooling could be like, decided to take the risk, and found out for ourselves that we loved it. The benefits are apparent to us as we look at our children, and we experience great joy seeing the love of learning and life so vibrant and alive in them.

That doesn't mean we don't have rough days. Days when we're a little tired, we have a short fuse, and things just aren't going as planned. Kids can be fussy, and we can be grumpy. That's why it helps to think about why we're choosing this unschooling approach. And I get it, days like these we may wonder ourselves, "Why the heck DID I choose to do this!" But then if you've already done the legwork, you can reach down and grab your spiral (or your google doc) to see what you wrote down for your reasons why.

I think it always helps to realize that every day is really still a choice. Every day we can decide to keep going with this unconventioal approach, or return to the mainstream. Knowing that we always have choices can help us through difficult days.

It's interesting, to me, that educational research, for a long time, has supported learning that is more play-based, delaying academic lessons, encouraging a more homelike setting. While we may be  aware  of this, most of us don't move in this direction until the status quo just doesn't work for us anymore.

So let's think about your "why?" Sit with it for a while.

If your child (or you) had a horrific experience in the schools, go ahead and start with the list of  "Why Leave School Behind?"  Many of us, when we remove our children from school have a lot of anger and disappointment at how events transpired. We can feel the schools misrepresented themselves or didn't really take our child's needs into account. And sometimes our anger is because we had this story in our head ( oh, it's always those stories in our heads, isn't it? ) of how we saw it all playing out. But now, that story isn't going to happen. Maybe never. And we may even have a little grief about that. It's ok. It's all a process that we have to walk through - and everyone's path is going to be different.

Once we've focused on the negative aspects - because sometimes they can be loud and distracting and demand our attention - it's time to think about what we're moving  toward.

What's our rationale for why unschooling is the  better  approach?

What I found fascinating - and still do - is how I and other families start with a few reasons to make this choice. But as time goes on, we add more and more to that list. We learn more about how unschooling works and we didn't even REALIZE some of the benefits we'd enjoy later down the road.

That's why it's nice to have your lists of "Why?"
Be sure to leave plenty of space to add more as time goes on!

How will we know they're learning if we unschool?
By Sue Patterson April 3, 2025
Sue's Unschooling Mom2Mom Podcast shares 5 Tips to help you KNOW your unschooled kids are actually learning - plus some bonus ideas to consider!
Seasonal Unschooling in the Sprint
By Sue Patterson March 23, 2025
Seasonal unschooling offers the structure many parents want to find. Find out the specific information about how Spring offers ways for homeschooled and unschooled children to learn more about traditional stubjects like language arts, math, science, and social studies.
Pi Day - The Quintessential Homeschool Holiday
By Sue Patterson March 13, 2025
Ready to celebrate Pi Day - as unschooling homeschoolers?
The Art of Noticing & Individualizing: Secrets from Stage Managers
By Sue Patterson March 7, 2025
Noticing and individualizing your child's learning is an art! This podcast shows how Unschooling parents can take some cues from stage managers - plus a free PDF to help you dive deeper!
Can we Talk? Is Homeschooling Not Working?
By Sue Patterson February 26, 2025
Can we Talk? Is Homeschooling Not Working? Sue Patterson offers solutions for homeschooling parents who are struggling and covers a few common questions.
By Sue Patterson February 20, 2025
This year, I'm turning 64! I know, most of you are decades younger than me, and that seems.... OLD.
Feeling Discouraged? You're not alone!
By Sue Patterson February 16, 2025
Sometimes parents can feel discouraged with the way their family's unschooling life is progressing - or not progressing. Here are some tips to help walk you through rough times.
By Sue Patterson February 7, 2025
Get on the email list to receive free monthly PDFs from Sue's vault of unschooling resources!
By Sue Patterson January 28, 2025
Let Go of Lesson Plans: Embrace Winter as Your Unschooling Curriculum
By Sue Patterson January 23, 2025
Do you think of Reading as the Holy Grail of Learning? Let's talk about that!
More Posts
Share by: